I haven't been able to stop thinking about "In Memoriam" -- the debut novel by Alice Winn, who was not yet 30 when she wrote it (!) -- and wanting to talk about it with other readers, since I first read it almost three (!) years ago. (Dh also read it, at my behest, and agreed with me that it was a wonderful book.) It was probably my favourite book that I read that year and, three years after its release, it's still rated very highly (average 4.49 stars) on Goodreads.
"In Memoriam" is the story of two teenaged boys, Sidney Ellwood and Henry Gaunt, and what happens to them and their friends from Preshute (a traditional upper-class English boarding school) when the First World War breaks out in 1914. The two harbour secret, unrequited passions for each other, at a time and place when same-sex "crushes" were tolerated in the school environment, but homosexuality was a crime in broader society.
Ellwood is Jewish, handsome and romantic, a budding poet who quotes Tennyson, Shakespeare and Keats at every opportunity. Gaunt is more repressed and introverted, and tormented by his feelings for Ellwood. Pressured by his family -- originally from Germany -- to demonstrate their patriotism by enlisting, and confronted by a young woman who hands him a white feather (a symbol of cowardice, presented to young men not in uniform), Gaunt signs up -- followed by Ellwood, and many of their other young classmates.
None of them has any idea of what they're about to endure.
This is (still) not an easy book to read. The carnage of the Great War is graphically described, and horrifying to read about. The casualty lists and "In Memoriams" in the school newspaper, the Preshutian, are still hard to read... such a horrible waste of young life. The toll the war takes on the survivors (those who fought, and those at home) is also hard to read about.
But it's still incredibly powerful and moving book, on second reading. (Kleenex was still needed.)
This time around, I found myself taking greater note of the character of Maud, Gaunt's younger sister, a VAD (Voluntary Aid Detachment) hospital volunteer, who is (also!) in love with Ellwood. Although she only plays a supporting role here, she was one reason why I thought this book might be of interest to the group. I was reminded of the book "Singled Out" by Virginia Nicholson (which Winn mentions in the end notes) -- reviewed here, also worth a read.
I also noticed more clearly this time around how the author used various representative characters to explore some very 21st century themes (outside of Gaunt & Ellwood's forbidden love): Gaunt's Indian friend Gideon Devi (racism), Ellwood (anti-Semitism), Hayes (class prejudices -- on both sides of the divide), Maud (feminism). Perhaps it was a little obvious, and a little unrealistic that people within the book would be so understanding/accepting of these things in the early 20th century? (Or maybe they were, and we just haven't heard as much about it?)(I also noticed the author giving a shoutout to Yael van der Wouden, among other writers who inspired and supported her. Van der Wouden is the author of the more recent novel "The Safekeep" -- reviewed here -- which is also about the trauma of war and its aftermath, and forbidden love.)
My original review (posted here) gave this book 4.5 stars on StoryGraph, rounded up to 5 on Goodreads, "because I really did think it was a wonderful book." That rating still stands.
This was Book #13 read to date in 2026 (and Book #3 finished in June), bringing me to 33% of my 2026 Goodreads Reading Challenge goal of 40 books. I am (for the moment, anyway...!) 5 books behind pace to meet my goal. :( You can find reviews of all my books read to date in 2026 tagged as "2026 books."
















